| 1947 | Jim Rila | 1972 | Bruce Miller | 1997 | Brian Seeton | |
| 1948 | Jim Rila | 1973 | Dan O'Loughlin | 1998 | Brian Seeton/Chris Sandrock | |
| 1949 | Gene Custer | 1974 | Dan O'Loughlin | 1999 | Joe Bomba | |
| 1950 | Jim Ressler | 1975 | Kirk Albrecht | 2000 | Joe Bomba | |
| 1951 | Jack Pettit | 1976 | Chris Andrews | 2001 | Greg Clements | |
| 1952 | Jack Pettit/Ronnie Potts | 1977 | Chris Andrews | 2002 | Brandon Holman | |
| 1953 | Ronnie Potts | 1978 | Greg Browning | 2003 | Ross Miltner | |
| 1954 | Vince Strasavich | 1979 | Brad Bowersox | 2004 | Logan Mark | |
| 1955 | Gary Strobel | 1980 | Bruce Metzger | 2005 | Logan Mark | |
| 1956 | Wallace Smith | 1981 | Russell Spees | 2006 | Travis Gulling | |
| 1957 | Roger Vincent | 1982 | Keith Boyer | 2007 | Wes Krigbaum | |
| 1958 | Buddy White | 1983 | Karl Smith | 2008 | Jon Reisdorf | |
| 1959 | Larry Hostetler | 1984 | Mark Miller | 2009 | Jon Reisdorf | |
| 1960 | Don Simonson | 1985 | Mark Miller | 2010 | Clayton Smith/Ben Miller | |
| 1961 | Tom Borden | 1986 | Mark Steinbach | 2011 | Ben Miller | |
| 1962 | Henry Bunting | 1987 | Douglas Brown | 2012 | James Lovett | |
| 1963 | Henry Bunting | 1988 | Kenneth Kramer | 2013 | Collin James Appleby | |
| 1964 | Joel Carmany | 1989 | Brian Woodruff | 2014 | Brayden Quick | |
| 1965 | Tom Nohl | 1990 | Jonathan Stucky | 2015 | Hunter Flinner | |
| 1966 | Chuck Caldwell | 1991 | Jeff Conley | 2016 | Hunter Flinner | |
| 1967 | Scott Chandler | 1992 | Brian Lewis | 2017 | Derick Brietenbucher | |
| 1968 | Steve Cornett | 1993 | Eric Matheny | 2018 | Derick Brietenbucher | |
| 1969 | John Lautzenheiser | 1994 | Eric Matheny | 2019 | Christian Stark | |
| 1970 | Robert J Bauman | 1995 | Daniel Lutz | 2020 | Christian Stark | |
| 1971 | Robert J Bauman | 1996 | Daniel Lutz |